
Rare Beauty's Sincerely Me Mini Eye Essentials was a limited-edition $25 set released in August 2023. It combined a mini version of the Discovery Eyeshadow Palette with a mini Perfect Strokes Universal Volumizing Mascara. It has since sold out, so here's what was in it and what you can still buy.
What Was in the Set?
1. Mini Discovery Eyeshadow Palette. Five shades, described by Rare Beauty as rich, buttery and crease-resistant, running from velvety mattes to metallics:
2. Perfect Strokes Universal Volumizing Mascara Mini. Rare Beauty says it gives lifted, lengthened lashes with buildable volume, using a weightless formula and an eye-hugging brush made for every lash type.
Can You Still Buy It?
Confirmed: a search of rarebeauty.com for "Sincerely Me" returned no results on September 25, 2026. As a limited edition, the set wasn't expected to be restocked.
Still available: the Perfect Strokes Universal Volumizing Mascara Mini is still sold on its own for $14. Rare Beauty also lists a Selena's Essential Eye Duo ($28), a different, current eye set.
Not confirmed: whether any of the five mini palette shades are sold in a full-size palette today.
Was It Good Value at $25?
Our take: today the mascara mini alone costs $14, so the set priced the five-pan palette at about $11. For a limited-edition palette with a glitter and two metallics, that was a good deal, and it's why these small sets tend to sell out quickly.
FAQ
Is Rare Beauty cruelty-free? Rare Beauty markets itself as cruelty-free. Check its site for current certifications.
Will Sincerely Me come back? Rare Beauty hasn't announced a return. We'll update this post if it does.
September 25, 2026 update: we checked availability on rarebeauty.com and added what's still sold from the set.
Did you get the Sincerely Me set? Which shade did you use most? Tell us in the comments.









